With Shopify POS exchange v2, Shopify streamlined the entire returns and exchange experience.
Instead of creating separate orders for returns or exchanges, all related items (returned items, new exchange items, refunds, and additional payments) are tracked within the original order record in Shopify. This offers a unified view, giving customers a clear transaction history and allowing store staff to manage the entire Shopify POS exchange process from one screen without juggling multiple order numbers.
Before diving into the integration challenges, understanding the benefits of Shopify POS exchange v2 is key. Learn more in our introductory blog post: Understanding the Benefits of Shopify POS Exchange v2.
This unified approach, while simplifying the user experience, presents hurdles for accurate accounting and order processing, especially when integrating with systems like NetSuite. The main challenges stemming from this, which we will explore in detail below, involve handling additions like new exchange items to orders that may already be closed or invoiced in the accounting system, and correctly processing returns when items from orders and exchanges are returned within a single Shopify return transaction.
Understanding Shopify POS Exchange v2 and the Integration Challenge
Challenge 1: Handling New Exchange Items Added to Existing Orders
An integration challenge arises from how Shopify POS exchange v2 handles new items added during an exchange. While Shopify conveniently adds these items to the original order, most accounting systems, including NetSuite, operate differently. Once an order is posted and invoiced in the accounting system, it's typically considered immutable or 'locked' to maintain financial integrity. You generally cannot simply add new line items to such an order.
This creates a disconnect: Shopify shows one continuous order, but the accounting system cannot replicate this by modifying the original, posted order. Attempting to push these new exchange items directly to the closed original order in the accounting system will often result in errors or require manual intervention.
Integration Solution: Post Exchange Items as a Separate Order
• Create a new sales order in the accounting system for the items the customer is receiving in the exchange.
• Mark the order with a clear prefix, such as EXCH- to distinguish it from the original order and maintain traceability.
• Balance the new order by:
- Applying the appropriate credit amount from the returned items.
- Accounting for any additional payment made by the customer in Shopify during the exchange.
This approach ensures that the accounting system reflects the transaction accurately, even though Shopify maintains it all within a single original order record.
Calculating the Correct Exchange Credit
A further complication arises because Shopify, while tracking the items involved and any additional payment, doesn't explicitly state the monetary credit value being applied from the return towards the new exchange items. This credit must be calculated by the integration system to ensure accurate accounting in systems like NetSuite.
The exchange credit is determined by subtracting the additional amount paid by the customer (if any) from the total cost of the new items selected for the exchange. The result represents the value contributed by the returned items.
For example,
• A customer returns a shirt worth $50.
• They choose new exchange items (e.g., jeans) costing $70.
• Shopify records that the customer paid an additional $20.
• The exchange credit is calculated as follows: $70 (cost of new jeans) - $20 (additional payment) = $50.
• This calculated $50 credit, representing the value applied from the return, needs to be correctly accounted for when creating the new exchange order in the accounting system.
Challenge 2: Processing Returns Containing Items From Multiple Order Sources
The second major challenge arises when a customer returns items that originated from both the initial sale and a subsequent exchange. Because Shopify POS exchange v2 keeps everything tied to the original Shopify order number, a single return transaction in Shopify might include:
Items from separate exchange order (created earlier as described in Challenge 1).
However, most accounting systems like NetSuite require a return authorization or credit memo to be linked back to a single, specific sales order. They aren't usually designed to handle a single return transaction that references items from multiple distinct orders simultaneously.
Integration Solution: Split the Return Transaction
When a mixed return like this comes from Shopify, the integration process must:
• Split the return into multiple returns before sending it to the accounting system.
• Map each returned item back to its corresponding source order (either the original sale or the exchange order).
• Ensure accurate inventory and financial updates against the correct orders.
Reconciling Refunds for Split Returns
Handling refunds in Shopify POS exchange v2 also requires careful consideration for reconciliation. Although the returned items might be recorded across multiple return documents in the accounting system (one for original items, one for exchange items), the customer receives a single refund amount from Shopify. Splitting this single refund value across multiple backend return documents would complicate matching it back to the Shopify transaction.
Best Practice for Reconciliation
• Create a standalone credit memo in the accounting system for the total refunded amount.
• This credit memo matches the single Shopify refund transaction, even though the item-level returns are recorded on multiple return documents.
• Tag the credit memo with the original Shopify order ID. This ensures that auditors and finance teams can trace the refund back to the Shopify transaction, making reconciliation easier and audit trails clearer.
• This approach keeps the financial records clean, ensures order-level accuracy, and simplifies reconciliation between Shopify and the accounting system.
For example,
1. Initial Sale (Order #1001 in Accounting): Customer buys a $50 Shirt and a $30 Hat.
2. Exchange: Customer exchanges the $50 Shirt for $70 Jeans, paying $20 extra. A new order (#EXCH-1001) is created in Accounting for the $70 Jeans.
3. Later Return (via Shopify): Customer returns both the $70 Jeans (from the exchange) and the $30 Hat (from the original sale). Shopify processes a single refund of $100.
4. Accounting System Processing:
• The single Shopify return is split
Return Document 1 (linked to Order #1001): This shows the $30 Hat being returned.
Return Document 2 (linked to Order #EXCH-1001): This shows the $70 Jeans being returned.
• Standalone Credit Memo: A single credit memo for $100 is created in the accounting system
It matches the total refund processed by Shopify.
It serves as the primary document for reconciliation.
The Shopify Order ID is tagged or noted on the credit memo, ensuring easy traceability between systems and simplifying audits.
* * *
Navigating Shopify POS Exchange v2 Integration
Integrating Shopify POS exchange v2 feature, while beneficial for the customer experience, clearly presents significant backend challenges, particularly for accounting accuracy and order management system synchronization. As we've seen, correctly handling new items added to invoiced orders and processing returns containing items from multiple sources requires careful planning and robust integration logic. These complexities, including calculating exchange credits and splitting returns while ensuring unified refund reconciliation, need reliable solutions to maintain operational efficiency and financial integrity.
For businesses seeking to overcome these specific hurdles, HotWax Commerce offers capabilities designed to manage these Shopify POS exchange v2 synchronization challenges seamlessly out-of-the-box. To understand how these processes are handled in detail, please refer to our documentation Shopify POS Exchanges.
To see how it all comes together, schedule a quick call.
